If all your memories were erased, would you still be the same person?

[23 Na Pachara045นิสิตฝึกสอน]

No, I do not think so but actually perharps. A person identity is the final product of people's experience. Erasing the memories of that person is the same thing as erasing the experience. Many factors can form a person's identity like family, peers, community, school, ect. That is what we call Agents of socialization. Thtough socializing, people can develep their own identity. But evgen you still not be the same as time changes people. Just like how yesterday you is not current who you are now.

Na pachara 045 2EN

[22Tiraphat015ครูผู้ช่วย]

If my own memories were erased, I will be the same person because if anything in my life but erased, but it cannot change myself. I’m still alive and I will have the new experience and the new memory that would be good than in the past. I believe that everything happened with the reason don’t let anything change yourself and still alive and make new experience to you.

Turaphat 015 2EN

[32Karabuning002ผู้ช่วยศาสตราจารย์]

If my all memories are gone I think I can be the same person because of empty memories but the same heart. I can make great memories as great as I can if I have my lover who always loves and around me to make the best new memories with me. Although the last memories are very well if I have the same person in my life I can make it better than the last nevertheless it won’t be the same anymore. However, my memories can be erased but I wish I could have the same person who loves me and create a good time together.

Karabuning 002 3EN

[32Phichayapak062ผู้ช่วยศาสตราจารย์]

If all my memories were erased, I think I’d still be the same person because without any memories, I’d return to my original self. I wouldn’t remember the experiences that shaped me into the person I am today. However, my approach to life would probably still remain the same.

Phichayapak 3EN 062

[31Khampeeraphan003ผู้ช่วยศาสตราจารย์]

How can I predict this situation! I don’t have any idea for this question. I think if I lose my memory, I will cry and regret for myself. I think I can’t be the same person if I lose my memory. Everything that I did, everyone that I met also my whole life. I should keep my memory in the cloud like on the internet, so I can keep my memories forever.

Khampeeraphan 003 3EN

[23Sinanya059ครูชำนาญการ]

This reminds me of one movie called “ eternal sunshine of the spotless mind” if your memories are erased you’re not gonna change for real cause you are who you are you will never change it’s only changed when time passes by. I don’t know tho but you are the same person same old heart same old feelings eventually you gonna end up like the same as you were. Dang it philosophy !!

Sinanya 059 2EN

[23Gamonphon034ผู้ช่วยศาสตราจารย์]

In my opinion I think not.I think the person that we’re today it’s all comes from memories ,come from anything that you faces in your life,Come from experience that you have.If memories were eraser I think we will not the same person we will start to be someone  that will be something follows something you faces.

Gamonphon 034 2EN

[23Kanyawee037ผู้ช่วยศาสตราจารย์]

I think I still have some of myself left, but I may not be the same person. Right now, there are some things I want to fix and make them better, and there are some things I want to erase from my mind because it's so hard to live without thinking about them. But everything that has happened has always been good, and I want to remember everything so that I can still be the same person.

Kanyawee 037 2EN

[32Sarunporn034ผู้ช่วยศาสตราจารย์]

This is an interesting question. In my opinion, I think no. If all of my memory is gone, I can't be the same person at all because I don't know anything about myself from the old version. This question can be a topic for research.

Sarunporn 034 3EN

[24Piyathida020ผู้ช่วยศาสตราจารย์]

No, I don’t think I will be the same person because memories created my personality. If I lost all of my memories I would be an empty heart don’t know what to do, don’t know who am I. Why it’s sound like a novel

Piyathida 020 2EN

[31Siriruethai057ผู้ช่วยศาสตราจารย์]

I’m not sure what’s the answer LMAO. I think who I am is made from everything in my life, example my family, my old friend or every situation that I happened to me. So I think I’m not the same person like before except if situation that happened to me or every one around me is the same before I lost my memories.

Siriruethai 057 3EN

[23Somphida033ผู้ช่วยศาสตราจารย์]

If my memories were erased I would be same person. I think behavior and habits still stay in me. Memory is a thing in my brain one day we can forget that but my own personality will be the same always.

Somphida 033 2EN

[23Kornrawee035ผู้ช่วยศาสตราจารย์]

I think if all my memories were erased, I wouldn't be the same person. I wouldn't remember what I've done, dreamed, or had passion about something. So, it will make me have another personality or habits that change my mind. Also, my life wouldn't be the same, and how I live as well.

Kornrawee 035 2EN

[24Nutjarin016ผู้ช่วยศาสตราจารย์]

If my university friends see me, they probably say that I'm not the same person, but if it's my high school friends and my family, they would say that I'm the same person. Since I studied here, my personality has changed from my reality because, well, you know that when in Rome, do as the Romans do, so yeah, I changed because of that. Actually, I was a very fun and friendly person, but now I kind of a quiet and bad at interacting with people, so like I said, my university friends wouldn't believe that is me in the first place, lol.

Nutjarin 016 2EN

[32Patcharin026ครูเชี่ยวชาญพิเศษ]

If all my memories were erased, I would change. First of all, if my memories were erased I would lose all of my experience. I would change because I cannot remember someone. I would have forgotten all of what I have learned.

Patcharin 026 3EN

[31Chinnapat013ครูชำนาญการ]

If I lost all my memories, I would never be the same person again. All the things that have happened in my life have shaped me into who I am today. I would feel so lost and confused.

Chinnapat 013 3EN

[32Siraprapha036ครูเชี่ยวชาญ]

If all of my memories are gone, I still want to be the same person. I think I as now the best version of myself. I'm no need to change myself, even my memories are gone.

Siraprapha 036 3EN